At the Short Family Agency, we place a lot of emphasis on building strong relationships with our insurance partners so that our clients have access to the the most respected leaders in the insurance industry, especially when the unexpected happens. Many of our partner companies now offer direct claim reporting to save you time. Here is a list of our partner companies along with their claims contact information.
American Alternative Insurance Corporation
800-564-1799
American Commerce Insurance Company
877-224-5677
American Modern
800-543-2644
Andover (Bay State Insurance Company, Cambridge Mutual Fire Insurance Company, Merrimack Mutual Fire Insurance Company)
800-225-0770
Arrowhead Exchange
800-905-7550
Butwin Insurance Group
516-466-4200, option 0
Chubb (Great Northern Insurance Company, Vigilant Insurance Company)
800-252-4670, option 1
CNA Insurance
800-377-3328
Cumberland Mutual Fire Insurance Company
800-232-6992, option 8
Farmers Insurance Group
800-435-7764
Fidelity National
800-220-1351, option 1
Fireman’s Fund (Surety)
888-347-3428
Foremost Insurance Company
800-527-3907
Franklin Mutual Insurance Company (FMI)
800-842-0551, option 2
GMAC Insurance
800-468-3466
Hagerty
866-740-5417
Hanover
800-628-0250
Hartford
800-327-3636
Liberty Underwriters / Safeco
877-538-1920
Main Street America
877-425-2467
Merchants Insurance Group (Merchants National Insurance Company, Merchants Preferred Insurance Company, Merchants Mutual Group)
1-800-322-8608
Metlife Home
800-854-6011, option 2
Nautilus Insurance Company
800-334-5579
North Light Specialty
866-430-0902
Occidental Insurance
877-304-4785, option 1
One Beacon
877-248-6880
Pacific Specialty
800-962-1172, option 3
Peerless Insurance
800-522-7152
Philadelphia Contributionship Insurance Company (Germantown Insurance Company)
888-627-1752
Email: claims@contributionship.com
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company
800-333-7642, option 4
Preserver
212-655-2061
Progressive
800-274-4499
RLI
800-624-1109
Safeco
877-566-6601, option 1, then 1
Selective Insurance Company of America (Selective Auto Insurance Company of New Jersey)
1-866-455-9969
Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company
(800) 220-1351
claims@stillwaterinsurance.com
The Providence Mutual Insurance Company
877-763-1800
Tower Insurance Company (Castlepoint)
888-856-5522, option 1
twrclaims@twrgrp.com
Travelers (Travelers Commercial Policies)
Home, Personal Property, Boat: 800-252-4633, option 1
Commercial Policies: 888-661-3938
Universal North America
866-999-0898
USLI
888-875-5231
Utica First
315-736-2139
Zurich North America
866-972-7378